How to Price the Unpriceable??

I bought a book at a yard sale a few weeks back–one book among many–because the title intrigued me. I almost didn’t pony up the money because the cover was a bit dirty, but I decided “what the heck.”

I got my books home and discovered that my “dirty” book was worse than I thought. It had a stamp along the top page edges “Public Library, Mill Valley” and a tiny stamp inside saying “GIFT.” (Darn, it’s ex-library.) But worse, I discovered a few interior stains and 3 pages that had thick black pen notations at the bottom.  This was a book that had been read and appreciated. This is a book with personality.


Now, books with personality can be hard sells and I almost tossed it on my Goodwill pile thinking it might not be worth my effort to sell…then I started doing some research.

It’s a 1937, first edition “The Legacy of Asia and Western Man, A Study of the Middle Way” by famed Buddhist Alan W. Watts published in Great Britain…and nobody, but nobody has one currently for sale. Not on Amazon, Alibris, Ebay, Etsy, AbeBooks. I checked on and the only sale of this book title was for a 1938 University of Chicago version.


Then I checked World Catalog, a site which allows you to find books in libraries. I figured if this book was in a lot of public libraries it probably wasn’t worth much. The nearest library that has a copy is the University of London! Some 5000 miles away.

Well, now I’m stumped! This is starting to feel like a rare book. I’ve even tried to track down the print run information for this edition.  Were 500 books printed or 5000 or??

So, right now this book is unpriceable!  It could be priceless even in this condition. It could have been a gift from Alan Watts to the Mill Valley Library as he lived around there for a time. I just don’t know. Guess I have to dig deeper to figure this all out.

Your advice is welcome!!

UPDATE 11/13/14: Reader Mike has the same 1937 book, but inscribed and signed by Alan Watts and given to his soulmate poet Jean Burden in 1958. In the inscription, Alan notes “this is now a very rare volume.” Fabulous find Mike!



  1. Brian Abate

    How exciting!


    1. Brian, it is exciting…though I’m not feeling too confident about this one yet! But this year has had some really good purchases and sales. I feel fortunate!!! – Karen


  2. Mike

    I have a copy also… Like to hear what you have found


    1. Hi Mike…so far I have no info…a friend of a friend in the bookselling biz. in the UK was going to help me, but hasn’t so far 😦 – Karen


  3. Mike

    I have a first edition too…mine is signed and inscribed by Alan Watts . He has a wonderful hand.


    1. WOW Mike…this has got to be worth some $$$!! – Karen


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s